The case of joelito filartiga and the clinic of hope authors. A suit claiming that pena irala d had tortured filartiga s p decedent to death while he was a police inspector general, was brought by. This book seeks to promote accountability for violations of international law. Penairala that the atca could be used to sue a paraguayan police officer for acts of torture that he had committed in paraguay. District court for the eastern district of new york, filartiga v. Criminal law, torturer, law of nations, international tort, filartiga v. A suit claiming that penairala d had tortured filartigas p decedent to death while he was a police inspector general, was brought by. This litigation provides victims a voice and promotes accountability for violations of international law. Joel filartiga and dolly filartiga charging former paraguayan official americo pena irala with the wrongful death of joelito filartiga.
The anatomy of torture a documentary history of filartiga. It presents filartiga as a documentary history an approach to legal scholarship that has become increasingly popular in recent years. It set the precedent for united states federal courts to punish nonamerican citizens for tortious acts committed outside the united states that were in violation of public international law the law of nations or any treaties to which the united states is a party. The court of appeals held that deliberate torture perpetrated under color of official authority violates universally accepted norms of the international law of human rights, regardless of the nationality of the parties. Pena irala is related with the death of seventeen year old boy under due to the. For purpose of the allen tort statute, torture may be considered to violate law of nations. Joel filartiga s, a paraguayan doctor, sons custodial death due to torture in police custody. Filartiga 277 demonstrated a preoccupation with the maintenance of internal order as a.
Beth van schaack, the story behind the case that launched a legal revolution. Filartiga and joel filartiga, plaintiffsappellants, v. The complaint alleged torture of the plaintiffs brother see below leading to his death. Professor william aceves engaging new volume the anatomy of torture. Studi kasus hukum internasional 7 studi kasus filartiga v. It has made clear that abusers of internationally defined human rights from other countries who find themselves in the united states can be. Pena irala is related with the death of seventeen year old boy under due to the torturer of the police under custody. Unlike traditional casebooks, this book emphasizes the dynamic nature of law. Major breakthrough or legal oddity, georgia journal of international and comparative law, 1990, vol. Penairala, which held that the ats permits claims for violations of modern international human rights law. Studi kasus filartiga v penairala, court of appeals 2nd circuit, 1980 diajukan untuk memenuhi satu komponen perkuliahan mata kuliah studi kasus hukum internasional oleh. Joel filartigas, a paraguayan doctor, sons custodial death due to torture in police custody. Shifting the lens on alien tort statute litigation 149 the complex relationship of the stroessner and marcos regimes with the usa.
The us can be bound by customary international law internationally, but the effect of cil in the us courts and in relationship to us federal law is uncertain. Article pdf available in human rights quarterly 304. Holt whenever there is a landmark case, in any field, there is a tendency for scholars and wouldbe scholars to rush to interpret it, predict its effect, and conclude whether it. As with many landmark decisions, the importance of the opinion in the filartiga v. In this case, deportation of pena irala and juana villalba will deprive plaintiffs of their right under the fifth amendment to prosecute this civil action against pena irala. The filartigas brought this action in the eastern district of new york against americo norberto pena irala pena, also a citizen of. View homework help filartiga v pena irala case brief. The alien tort statute does not grant new rights to aliens, but is simply an opening to the federal.
This article revisits the two seminal alien tort statute ats cases filartiga v. Pena lrala2 has helped to set united states judicial policy on a course of. Federal jurisdiction of alleged torturer under the. Pena irala1 case has little to do with the parties involved. Case brief filartiga v pena irala 1980 united states court of appeals for the second. The filartigas brought this action in the eastern district of new york against americo norberto pena irala 4 pena, also a citizen of paraguay, for wrongfully causing the death of dr. The filartigas brought this action in the eastern district of new york against americo norberto pena irala pena, also a citizen of paraguay, for wrongfully causing the death of dr. While the district court accepted the filartigas argument that torture violated the. Unlike traditional casebooks, this book emphasizes the.
He became known for his human rights activism after his son, joelito filartiga, who was killed by the police during the dictatorship of alfredo stroessner in 1976. Pena irala the facts of the case this case is related with dr. Hutapea 110110120241 fakultas hukum universitas padjadjaran bandung 2016. A suit claiming that penairala d had tortured filartigas p decedent to death while he was a police insp. His lifelong struggle for justice and human rights inspired an hbo film, one mans war, starring anthony hopkins as the. A suit claiming that pena irala d had tortured filartiga s p decedent to death while he was a police insp. The anatomy of torture a documentary history of filartiga v. Get free access to the complete judgment in filartiga v. Holt whenever there is a landmark case, in any field, there is a tendency for scholars and wouldbe scholars to rush to interpret it, predict its effect, and conclude whether it is good or bad law from their perspective. Shifting the lens on alien tort statute litigation.
Pena irala, one of the most significant examples of human rights litigation in the united states. The stay of deportation is here the necessary and, indeed, the only available remedy to ensure plaintiffs this right and to preserve the jurisdiction of this court. Filartiga caused an explosion of ats litigation in the decades that followed, but the supreme court has placed limits on ats jurisdiction in its recent jurisprudence. The suit was brought by an alien residing in the united states against a former official of paraguay then visiting the united states. However, cil has been prominently used in the human rights arena and has been interpreted by us courts. Pena irala, one of the most significant examples of human rights litigation in the u. Alien tort claims act united states 1789 britannica. The wellestablished universal prohibition of torture under international law, the court held, must be honoured in u.
Assuming the filartigas ultimately were able to obtain a. The landmark case pioneered the human rights application of a previously littleused 1789 federal statute, the alien. The court of appeals held that deliberate torture perpetrated under color of official authority violates universally accepted norms of the international law of human rights, regardless of the nationality of the parties, and that 28 u. Penairala dean rusk the decision of the second circuit court of appeals in the filartiga case probably will not stand as a landmark case with farreaching implications for the development of international law. Joel filartiga and dolly filartiga charging former paraguayan official americo penairala with the wrongful death of joelito filartiga.
A suit claiming that pena irala d had tortured filartiga s p decedent to death while he was a police inspector general, was brought by filartiga p. It is more likely to find its place as a legal oddity picked up in but see. Alientortstatutecasespostkiobelwhatarethekeydefenses. The government of paraguay, because of his efforts to help poor and. Upon ratification of the constitution, the thirteen former colonies were fused into a single nation, one which, in its relations with foreign states, is bound both to observe and construe the accepted norms of international law, formerly known as the law of. Download this paper open pdf in browser register to save articles to your library register. Penairala, one of the most significant examples of human rights litigation in the u. Filartiga, arrived in the united states in 1978 under a visitors visa, and has since applied for permanent political asylum. Pena lrala2 has helped to set united states judicial policy on a course of reform. William j aceves victims of human rights abuses have filed civil lawsuits in us courts to seek redress for their injuries. Penairala 3 tells the story of this system of civil enforcement developed through a rich account of the filartiga case and its progeny. Iralas motion, dismissing for lack of jurisdiction. Joel holden filartiga ferreira 15 august 1932 5 july 2019 was a paraguayan doctor, artist and human rights activist. To the contrary, this article exposes how filartiga and marcos recast as entirely foreign vio.
294 1129 720 716 245 243 1305 279 93 203 800 751 1410 207 1224 1121 445 444 1460 947 843 1115 1269 1255 690 421 17 1329 639 1479 593 290 59 1388 519 1237